New York State Sportswriters Association   
    
Search

 

NYSSWA All-State plaques

John Moriello's NYSSWA blog
Monday, Oct. 18, 2010: Sec. 2 football seeding process questioned
   Leading off today: At first glance, the seeding process for the Section 2 Class C football tournament doesn't seem to make much sense. It doesn't look any prettier after second, third or fourth glances, though the unwieldy system may ultimately have gotten things right.

   Granville ended up being the odd team out in a three-way tie for third place in Class C North. Mechanicville and Tamarac were awarded the No. 3 and 4 slots, respectively, to advance to the Section 2 playoffs.

   The problem began many months ago. With newbie program Ichabod Crane playing an independent schedule, the section's 17 other Class C teams were broken into two divisions rather than three. With only seven available scheduling blocks, the football committee devised a Big Ten-like scheduling format in which North Division teams would not play all of the other teams in the division.

   Further complicating the issue, they also decided that not everyone would play the same number of games and created a rule that ended up treating Granville (4-2 in the North, 4-3 overall), Mechanicville (4-2, 4-3) and Tamarac (4-2, 5-2) as essentially tied in the North Division.

   (Editor's note: Feel free to move onto the next blog topic, because it gets a lot more gruesome from here.)

   Section 2 did have the foresight to make head-to-head results the first tiebreaker to settle problems.

   Unfortunately, they applied head-to-head criteria in a way in which no reasonable person would ever do it. Mechanicville beat Tamarac 28-27 on Friday in OT, and Tamarac beat Granville 24-22 on Sept. 18. But Granville and Mechanicville did not play each other this season, so there was no way of making an equitable ruling based on the available data.

   But the football committee did it anyway.

   "I told the kids last week, ‘Win and you’re in,’” Granville coach Mario Torres told The Post-Star. “I don’t want to look into my 35 kids’ faces and tell them despite all your hard work, you got voted out by an interpretation of the rules.”

   Torres rightly points out that his kids never had a chance to play Mechanicville to potentially leave everyone 1-1 head-to-head. He said Class C coaches met Wednesday night and voted to go with "quarter points" -- next on the tiebreaker list -- to sort out a three-way tie, but sectional football chairman Gary VanDerzee brushed that aside.

   “The Class C coaches can have a meeting, they come in with their recommendations, but they’re not the governing body," he told the paper. "Section 2 is.”

   The quarter points tie-breaker probably would have gone against Granville anyway, but that's not the point. The football committee needs to spend less time railing at the NYSPHSAA over budget-inspired schedule cuts and more time creating sensible schedules and procedures.

   Boys soccer: Bronxville, ranked 16th in Class B by the NYSSWA, traveled to No. 7 Center Moriches on Saturday

  
and came away with a 5-1 victory. Ilya Dubinski had three goals and John Timoney added two goals and two assists to help the Broncos beat the reigning NYSPHSAA champs. Goalie Jack Conners stopped six shots.

   CTK PG to GMU: Christ The King point guard Corey Edwards committed to George Mason University

Read the tweets
   Many reporters use Twitter to deliver updates from fall sports contests. We track those tweets from a variety of venues 24/7. Visit the page to see what's going on.
Read the tweets

following a weekend recruiting visit.

   Edwards was a hot prospect before dislocating an ankle early in the CHSAA playoffs last March. Coupled with the shoulder injury that curtailed his freshman season, that scared off some schools -- but not George Mason.

   "I definitely think schools were saying that I was damaged goods or injury prone, but George Mason was there no matter what, since my freshman year," Edwards told The New York Daily News.

   Showing their support: In a show of support for former varsity head coach Ralph Novi, now an assistant, players and coaches on the Newark Valley varsity and JV football teams shaved their heads at a benefit pancake breakfast Saturday.

   That night, Novi was on hand as the Cardinals posted a 20-13 victory over Trumansburg to capture the Section 4 Division VI championship.

   "It was pretty emotional, especially after the game with all the kids seeing Ralph," coach Jack Short told The Press & Sun-Bulletin. "They really wanted to win it for him. He's a hero to a lot of kids on the team."

   Troy Schiess's 1-yard TD run late in the third quarter to cap a nine-play drive was the winning margin.

   Short told the paper Novi's cancer is not terminal and that he is wrapping up treatment.

   Hottest harriers: The outstanding TullyRunners.com site ranks Burnt Hills-Ballston Lake senior Otis Ubriaco as the state's No. 1 male runner heading into the final month of the cross country season.

   Ubriaco grades out slightly ahead of Sam Place of Saratoga and Edward Owens of Packer Collegiate in the extensive listings.

   The girls list is topped by No. 1 Aisling Cuffe of Cornwall, followed by Fayetteville-Manlius soph Jillian Fanning and Pittsford Mendon's Shaylyn Tuite.

   Extra points: Phoenix backup quarterback Mariah Provost scored her first career touchdown on a four-yard run in a 33-19 loss to Homer over the weekend.


Read previous blog entries from John Moriello. | Send us an e-mail. | Subscribe to RSS feed.


HOME | BLOG | RANKINGS | BRACKETS | REFERENCE | KERR CUP | ABOUT US | ©2025 Abbott Trento Online Media, LLC. All rights reserved. | Contact us via e-mail.

→ Recent blogs and news
  • 5/28/26: Coach Bill Aris on leave during F-M probe
  • 5/28/26: Eligibility issue costs Ross spot in final
  • 5/24/26: New York flag football playoff scoreboard
  • 5/24/26: Penalties reduced for Stepinac basketball
  • 5/18/26: Girls basketball all-state team (small schools)
  • 5/11/26: Girls basketball all-state team (large schools)
  • 5/9/26: 2 adults arrested after L.I. flag football game
  • 5/7/26: NYSPHSAA committee quashes Sec. 1 push

  • 5/4/26: Previewing the quarterly NYSPHSAA meeting
  • 5/3/26: Marcellus 3-sport star hits another milestone
  • 4/29/26: Boys basketball all-state team (large schools)
  • 4/28/26: Arch. Stepinac facing stiff CHSAA penalties
  • 4/25/26: Private vs. public: Assessing where we're at
  • 4/24/26: NYSPHSAA rejects push for separate playoffs
  • 4/22/26: Boys basketball all-state team (small schools)
  • 4/20/26: Section 1 may make move vs. private schools
  • 4/19/26: Bennett to play St. Francis in football opener
  • 4/13/26: Albertus Magnus' Buckley changing duties

  • 4/6/26: You're not imagining it's been a wet spring
  • 4/2/26: Plainedge reversal puts 8th-grader on field
  • 4/1/26: Where the private vs. public issue stands
  • 3/31/26: Dior Johnson is on the move ... again
  • 3/20/26: Class changes and Albion-Medina merger
  • 3/18/26: Section 3 foes drop CBA from schedule
  • 3/8/26: Warwick vaulter, McQuaid swimmers win big
  • 3/5/26: Will. East baseball coach reappointed
  • 3/1/26: Wrapup of weekend N.Y. championship action
  • 2/18/26: Mass. coaches out over recorded comments

  • 2/14/26: Warsaw ends season as probe continues
  • 2/12/26: Section 4 reporter Kevin Stevens, 62, dies
  • 2/5/26: Public vs. private issue under study again
  • 2/2/26: NYSPHSAA meeting will revive hot topic
  • 1/31/26: Iona Prep, Syr. CBA to meet in grid opener
  • 1/26/26: College recruiting landscape has changed
  • 1/22/26: Blackford steps down at Westmoreland
  • 1/18/26: Sec. 2 coach accused of hitting athlete
  • 1/17/26: Ref stricken at Nassau Co. basketball game
  • 1/14/26: NYSSWA all-state football team, Part 2

    MORE BLOGS FROM THE CURRENT SCHOOL YEAR

  •    NYSSWA Road to Syracuse football website    NYRA Awards and Trophies