New York State Sportswriters Association   
    
Search

 

NYSSWA All-State plaques

Softball
NYSSWA all-stars, 2026
N.Y. State Sportswriters Association all-state awards
-- $5 for one blank certificate, $4 extra for a second, $3 per for each after that. Payable to NYSSCOGS, 3350 Rt 28, Herkimer, NY 13350.

-- Online ordering of certificates with the details already printed via PayPal or credit card.

NYSSWA all-state plaque The NYSSWA also offers all-state plaques for sale.

These 7"x9" awards feature black laser type on gold plates that are mounted on beautiful cherry laminate backings suitable for wall displays.

 


NYSSCOGS All-State Softball Team Edited by Perry L. Novak

Class AAA

Player of the Year: Matti Johnston (Corning-4) 

First Team
01 12 P Tara Murphy (North Rockland)
02 11 OF Ava Taber (Saratoga Springs)
04 12 P Matti Johnston (Corning)
04 11 OF Lauren Derosa (Corning)
06 12 P Alyssa Brunner (Lancaster) 
06 10 P Maddy Matthews (Lancaster)
08 12 P Caroline Ferchland (Oceanside)
09 12 P Avery Ogden (Pine Bush)
11 12 P Kate Schweitzer (Commack)
C  09 P/OF Olivia Feldman (St. Anthony's)

Second Team
01 12 CF Carly Voce (Clarkstown South)
02 12 1B Hailey Farquharson (Shenendehowa)
08 12 C Maeve Schierck (Massapequa)
08 10 CF Sienna Erker (Massapequa)
09 11 CF Parker Mullarkey (Newburgh Free Academy)
11 12 3B Jordyn Kwasna (Riverhead)
11 11 C Delaney Mathes (Sachem North)
C  11 3B Makayla Martinez (St. Anthony's)
C  12 P/OF Kimmy Piazza (Archbishop Molloy)
C  12 OF Sienna Bocchino (Xaverian)

Third Team
01 11 P Alexis Tighe (White Plains)
01 11 SS Cara Luna (Clarkstown South)
02 12 INF Ava Goodman (Saratoga Springs)
03 12 SS Sydney Rockwell (Cicero-North Syracuse)
04 10 DP Hannah Kauffman (Corning)
08 12 SS Karley Handleman (Oceanside)
11 11 P Julianna Russ (Ward Melville)
11 12 P Danielle Brennan (Sachem North)
C  12 SS/P Molly Silecchia (Kellenberg)
C  12 SS Leanna Chow (Moore Catholic)

Fourth Team
01 12 SS Ava Ritterman (White Plains) 
02 12 INF Emelya Pardo (Shenendehowa)
08 11 LF Katy Love (Massapequa)
08 12 1B Ella Lanza (Syosset)
09 11 SS/3B Callie Exarchakis (Monroe-Woodbury)
11 11 SS Madison Johnston (Commack)
11 08 P Brynn Iacovone (Walt Whitman) 
C  12 C Te'a Ramirez (St. Joseph by the Sea)
C  11 DP Brianna Loveridge (Moore Catholic)
C  12 SS Sophia Lee (St. Anthony's)

Fifth Team
01 12 C Paige Hotle (Roy C. Ketcham)
01 12 P Kayla Dwyer (Clarkstown South)
02 12 U Chloe Alexander (Colonie)
03 12 OF Kierstyn McGraw (Cicero-North Syracuse)
05 12 C Elizabeth Rinella (Rush-Henrietta)
06 12 C Brennah Dewald (Lancaster)
08 10 P Samantha Szypula (Plainview JFK)
09 12 U Payton Croce (Pine Bush)
11 10 SS Amari Quinn (Ward Melville)
11 12 C Lianna Mills (Central Islip)

Class AA

Player of the Year: Ava Papaleo (Ursuline-1)

First Team
01 12 CF Ava Papaleo (Ursuline) 
01 11 C Sophia Gutierrez (Eastchester) 
02 12 P Sophia Galligan (Columbia)
03 12 SS Megan Woodridge (Fayetteville-Manlius)
04 10 P Erin Gowe (Vestal)
05 12 CF Ella Maley (Penfield)
06 12 C Julia Ford (Frontier)
06 11 OF Addy Mulone (Williamsville North)
06 12 OF Addison D'Andrea (North Tonawanda)
08 12 CF Sophia Nicastro (Calhoun)

Second Team
02 12 P Ava Yahoudy (Burnt Hills-Ballston Lake)
02 12 U Stella Guzek (Columbia)
03 12 CF Anna Egan (Fayetteville-Manlius)
04 12 3B Caitlin Yearick (Horseheads)
05 11 SS Kinsley Keil (Webster Schroeder)
06 11 SS Ella Hernandez (Orchard Park)
08 12 P Brooke Simmons (Glen Cove)
09 10 P/OF Addison Freiberger (Goshen)
11 12 1B Kayla Varga (East Islip)
11 10 P Caitlin Ropiak (East Islip)

Third Team
01 10 SS Kylie Reardon (Eastchester) 
02 11 P Lyla Hanlon (Bethlehem) 
03 12 C Alanna Bowman (West Genesee)
04 12 SS Maryn Morse (Union-Endicott)
05 12 U Orlando (Pittsford Sutherland)
06 11 P Jessica Lindhurst (North Tonawanda)
08 12 P Kaitlyn Santopietro (Garden City)
09 12 P Emily Sharper (Valley Central)
11 12 SS Katie Burke (Westhampton)
11 10 SS Jiselle Singh (Smithtown West)

Fourth Team
01 12 C Marlee Levin (Clarkstown North) 
01 11 P Casey Harsany (Ursuline)
02 10 P Lillian Smith (Queensbury)
03 11 P Maria Sweet (Oswego)
04 12 C Aubrey Rogers (Vestal)
05 12 P Jalissa Crittenden (Eastridge)
08 12 CF Avery Betancourt (Mepham)
09 12 3B Hannah Ringus (Minisink Valley)
11 12 SS Crisalyn Abruscato (Hauppauge)
11 12 P Izzy Briand (East Hampton)

Fifth Team
01 12 SS Camdyn Wilson (Mahopac) 
01 10 P Madi Miller (Harrison) 
01 11 P Kate Brown (Yorktown) 
05 11 SS Maddie Murphy (Hilton)
06 11 1B Abby D'Angelo (Williamsville North)
06 12 C Maris Huff (Niagara-Wheatfield)
06 12 OF Machala Musty (Hamburg)
08 12 LF Olivia Giordano (W.T. Clarke)
08 12 CF Devon Barley (Frank H. Carey)
08 12 P/INF Rylee Petruskie (Bethpage)

	

	
ADVERTISEMENT

Class A Player of the Year: Natalia Mancino (Averill Park-2) First Team 01 09 P Ashlyn Ryan (Pearl River) 02 12 SS Abbey Milazzo (Ichabod Crane) 02 12 C Natalia Mancino (Averill Park) 02 11 P Tori Cutler (Ichabod Crane) 03 11 P Ruby Gehringer (New Hartford) 04 12 SS Kaylee Hurba (Maine-Endwell) 06 12 SS Mattie Adamo (Starpoint) 08 10 P Rylie Betz (Seaford) 11 11 C Dellaney Schleider (Miller Place) 11 12 SS Laney Vomero (Miller Place) Second Team 01 12 P Haley Arvidson (Tappan Zee) 01 12 SS Katie Cole (Somers) 02 12 P Isabella Johnson (Glens Falls) 02 12 U Abigail Colwill (Averill Park) 03 09 C Addison Way (New Hartford) 04 09 P/OF Taylin Gonzalez (Waverly) 06 10 CF Brady Hoffhines (Depew) 08 11 P Lucy Olore (Wantagh) 09 11 P Samantha Maleck (Marlboro) 11 09 P Stella Roosa (Kings Park) Third Team 01 12 2B Angie Franzese (Pearl River) 01 12 C Alyssa Chiappa (Tappan Zee) 02 11 OF Ali Cox (Ichabod Crane) 02 12 INF Emily Aiossa (Averill Park) 04 12 CF Isabel Hunter (Maine-Endwell) 05 11 P Leah Sperry (Our Lady of Mercy) 06 12 CF Natalie Perzioso (Starpoint) 08 11 SS Cassidy Fitzgerald (Mineola) 11 11 C Sarah Benedict (Bayport-Blue Point) C 11 P Jaeda Bartfield (Holy Trinity) Fourth Team 01 11 SS Lexi Tomaselli (Pleasantville) 02 12 INF Audrey Coon (Averill Park) 03 10 OF Izzy McClusky (Chittenango) 04 10 SS/P Jenevie Gallusser (Oneonta) 05 12 CF Elizabeth Grazioplene (Batavia) 06 11 C Addison Lewis (Grand Island) 08 11 P/SS Savannah Speicher (Plainedge) 09 11 SS Alana Mower (Saugerties) 11 12 OF Raylee Weisman (Rocky Point) 11 12 SS Delilah Cummings (Sayville) Fifth Team 01 10 CF Elise Templeton (John Jay Cross River) 01 11 P Emily Boyle (Somers) 01 12 P Sofia Haber (Ardsley) 03 10 OF Sophia Barker (Camden) 05 11 P Arianna Almekinder (Batavia) 06 12 SS Ailey Moran (Iroquois) 06 12 P Aubrey DuVal (Cheektowaga) 09 12 2B Taylor Castellani (Marlboro) 11 12 P Lauren Hofmann (Islip) 11 11 SS Katherine Krayewski (Kings Park) Class B Player of the Year: Skylar Groom (Chatham-2) First Team 02 11 P Skylar Groom (Chatham) 02 11 P Toni DeLorenzo (Tamarac) 02 12 OF Samantha Silver (Chatham) 02 12 SS Meta Mountain (Chatham) 04 12 P Lil D'Introno (Susquehanna Valley) 04 12 C Danica LaBarre (Susquehanna Valley) 04 12 SS Kylee Richardson (Susquehanna Valley) 05 12 P Jessie Crye (Avon) 06 11 3B Grace Ricci (Springville) 10 12 SS/P Tessa Alguire (Canton) Second Team 02 12 P Kennedy Boisvert (Hoosick Falls) 03 12 C Millie Novitsky (Marcellus) 03 12 2B Erin Trinkaus (Utica Notre Dame) 03 10 C Sophie Wilmot (Cazenovia) 04 10 P Paige Ells (Watkins Glen/Odessa-Montour) 05 10 P/3B Ava Senka (Wayland-Cohocton) 05 12 SS Teagan Burke (Wellsville) 05 11 SS Gwyneth Panek (Waterloo) 06 10 1B Molly Earsing (Alden) 09 12 P/SS Cadie Hanaburgh (Spackenkill) Third Team 01 08 P Victoria Baron (Dobbs Ferry) 01 09 P Allegra Clementson (Haldane) 02 11 P Natalya Horton (LaSalle) 04 12 P/SS Olivia Somers (Whitney Point) 04 12 SS Piper Mason (Lansing) 05 12 C Kyah Lajewski (Mynderse) 06 12 OF Leanna Sargent (Eden) 07 11 P/SS Irelyn Ryan (Saranac) 09 11 SS Kerstin Knapp (Sullivan West) C 11 1B Renee Henning (Lancaster St. Mary's) Fourth Team 01 10 C Charlotte Picone (Rye Neck) 02 11 1B Erin Lee (Tamarac) 02 09 OF/P Laney Steltz (Chatham) 03 11 P/SS Jenna Wing (Solvay) 04 11 P/Util Aurora Parlo (Elmira Heights) 05 11 1B Makayla Smith (Bath) 05 10 SS Kylie Wilson (LeRoy) 06 12 P Kailey Truman (Allegany-Limestone) 08 11 INF Alexa Mifsud (Carle Place) 11 09 P Sophia Hagerty-Cori (Babylon)

ADVERTISEMENT

Class C Player of the Year: Addison Kota (Gowanda-6) First Team 01 11 P Katie Attwood (Tuckahoe) 02 10 P Emma Menge (Galway) 02 10 P Alexa Jansen (Greenwich) 04 12 SS Rae Anne Feeko (Tioga) 04 11 P/OF Ivy Tice (Deposit/Hancock) 04 12 1B Abbi Tracy (Union Springs) 04 10 3B Kadyn Appley (Deposit/Hancock) 06 12 SS/P Addison Kota (Gowanda) 09 10 P/1B Talia Durant (Pine Plains) 09 10 C Anna Essery (Pine Plains) Second Team 01 10 C Cayleigh Handel (Tuckahoe) 02 11 C Grace Schafer (Saratoga Catholic) 02 10 SS Ella Celani (Greenwich) 02 11 C Courtney Smith (Galway) 03 12 1B Haylee Bassett (McGraw) 03 12 INF Baylee Williams (Sandy Creek) 04 12 P/CF Paitlyn Delaney (Union Springs) 04 11 P/SS Alessandra Cafasso (Bainbridge-Guilford) 05 12 C Colleen Talty (Caledonia-Mumford) 05 10 P Kylee Whiting (Bolivar-Richburg) Third Team 01 12 1B Sophia Aqeel (North Salem) 02 10 1B Kiera Allen (Galway) 02 11 SS Olivia Mueller (Maple Hill) 03 11 C Katelynn Millard (McGraw) 03 12 P Madden Soluri (Sandy Creek) 04 11 1B Victoria Green (Deposit/Hancock) 05 12 OF Charity Scott (Letchworth) 05 12 OF Calla McCombs (Bloomfield) 06 11 P Emily Rhinehart (Falconer) 10 10 2B Avery Marcil (St. Lawrence) Fourth Team 02 11 P Charlotte Elbe (Berne-Knox-Westerlo) 03 11 P Eloise Freeth (Hamilton) 03 10 P Remington Stull (McGraw) 04 12 P Ann Harvatine (Southern Cayuga) 04 12 P/CF Grace Chapulnicki (Union Springs) 05 11 P/3B Grace Beach (Caledonia-Mumford) 05 12 P Adalyn Tham (Dundee/Bradford) 05 10 P Adelyn McDonald (Geneseo) 06 10 P Maddy Flint (Barker) 07 08 SS/P Lilian Davis (Ticonderoga) 09 07 P Sophia Ortiz (Burke Catholic) Class D Co-players of the Year: Savannah Durham (Oakfield-Alabama-5) and Hannah Tuttle (Windham-Ashland-Jewett-4) First Team 02 10 P Grace Depew (Argyle) 02 12 P Jadyn Mitchell (Fort Ann) 03 12 P/SS Payton Gerrard (Cincinnatus) 04 12 P Hannah Tuttle (Windham-Ashland-Jewett) 05 10 P Savannah Durham (Oakfield-Alabama) 05 12 C Morghyn Ross (Fillmore) 05 10 P/INF Meyah Putnam (Avoca/Prattsburgh) 05 11 2B Raine Denny (Oakfield-Alabama) 06 10 P Alexandra Kerstetter (Forestville) 10 12 SS Avery Chartrand (Harrisville) Second Team 02 09 C Hailey Lahinsky (Fort Ann) 02 11 2B Ava Cormie (Argyle) 03 12 INF Lucy Finch (Cincinnatus) 03 10 P Haley Haver (Poland) 04 11 P Jenna Wilson (Afton) 04 12 P Brinlee Wright (Charlotte Valley/Schenevus) 05 10 P/OF Arnie Sturtevant (Lyndonville) 05 12 SS Olivia Waters (Andover/Whitesville) 06 12 SS Carilene Sliwa (Forestville) 10 11 P/SS Maya Green (Hermon-DeKalb) Third Team 02 10 P Maddy Camadine (Northville) 02 12 1B Baylee Wright (Fort Ann) 02 12 P Genevieve Rickert (Duanesburg) 03 12 U Aurora McDermott (Fabius-Pompey) 04 12 3B Piper Cohane (Windham-Ashland-Jewett) 04 10 P Bailey Thayer (Cherry Valley-Springfield/Sharon Springs) 04 11 C Kylie Jordan (Windham-Ashland-Jewett) 05 12 SS Emma Thompson (Oakfield-Alabama) 05 11 P Lola Rivera (Northstar Christian) 07 11 U Addison Hurlbert (Crown Point)


HOME | BLOG | RANKINGS | BRACKETS | REFERENCE | KERR CUP | ABOUT US | ©2025 Abbott Trento Online Media, LLC. All rights reserved. | Contact us via e-mail.

→ Recent blogs and news
  • 6/25/26: All-state softball selections announced
  • 6/25/26: An NCAA change helpful to H.S. prospects
  • 6/16/26: Transgender athlete wins state track title

  • 6/12/26: St. Joe's investigating its baseball 'culture'
  • 6/9/26: Florida adding super playoff division
  • 5/28/26: Coach Bill Aris on leave during F-M probe
  • 5/28/26: Eligibility issue costs Ross spot in final
  • 5/24/26: New York flag football playoff scoreboard
  • 5/24/26: Penalties reduced for Stepinac basketball
  • 5/18/26: Girls basketball all-state team (small schools)
  • 5/11/26: Girls basketball all-state team (large schools)
  • 5/9/26: 2 adults arrested after L.I. flag football game
  • 5/7/26: NYSPHSAA committee quashes Sec. 1 push

  • 5/4/26: Previewing the quarterly NYSPHSAA meeting
  • 5/3/26: Marcellus 3-sport star hits another milestone
  • 4/29/26: Boys basketball all-state team (large schools)
  • 4/28/26: Arch. Stepinac facing stiff CHSAA penalties
  • 4/25/26: Private vs. public: Assessing where we're at
  • 4/24/26: NYSPHSAA rejects push for separate playoffs
  • 4/22/26: Boys basketball all-state team (small schools)
  • 4/20/26: Section 1 may make move vs. private schools
  • 4/19/26: Bennett to play St. Francis in football opener
  • 4/13/26: Albertus Magnus' Buckley changing duties

  • 4/6/26: You're not imagining it's been a wet spring
  • 4/2/26: Plainedge reversal puts 8th-grader on field
  • 4/1/26: Where the private vs. public issue stands
  • 3/31/26: Dior Johnson is on the move ... again
  • 3/20/26: Class changes and Albion-Medina merger
  • 3/18/26: Section 3 foes drop CBA from schedule
  • 3/8/26: Warwick vaulter, McQuaid swimmers win big
  • 3/5/26: Will. East baseball coach reappointed
  • 3/1/26: Wrapup of weekend N.Y. championship action
  • 2/18/26: Mass. coaches out over recorded comments

  • 2/14/26: Warsaw ends season as probe continues
  • 2/12/26: Section 4 reporter Kevin Stevens, 62, dies
  • 2/5/26: Public vs. private issue under study again
  • 2/2/26: NYSPHSAA meeting will revive hot topic
  • 1/31/26: Iona Prep, Syr. CBA to meet in grid opener
  • 1/26/26: College recruiting landscape has changed
  • 1/22/26: Blackford steps down at Westmoreland
  • 1/18/26: Sec. 2 coach accused of hitting athlete
  • 1/17/26: Ref stricken at Nassau Co. basketball game
  • 1/14/26: NYSSWA all-state football team, Part 2

    MORE BLOGS FROM THE CURRENT SCHOOL YEAR

  •    NYSSWA Road to Syracuse football website    NYRA Awards and Trophies