Key: (A)-AIS, (C)-CHSAA, (P)-PSAL. All others are NYPSHSAA schools.
| | Class AA | Class A | Class B | |
| 2023 | L.I. Lutheran (A) | St. Joe by the Sea (C) | Waterloo | |
| 2022 | South Shore (P) | Averill Park | Schalmont | |
| 2021 | No Tournament | | | |
| 2020 | No Tournament | | | |
| 2019 | Christ The King (C) | Pittsford Mendon | Irvington | |
| 2018 | Baldwin | Jamesville-DeWitt | Susquehanna Valley | |
| 2017 | South Shore (P) | Staten Is. Academy (A) | Bing. Seton Catholic | |
| 2016 | Ossining | Staten Is. Academy (A) | East Harlem Pride (P) | |
| 2015 | L.I. Lutheran (A) | Nazareth (C) | Staten Is. Academy (A) | |
| 2014 | L.I. Lutheran (A) | Cardinal O'Hara (C) | Utica Notre Dame | |
| 2013 | Bishop Ford (C) | L.I. Lutheran (A) | Irvington | |
| 2012 | Cicero-N. Syracuse | Bishop Loughlin (C) | Irvington | |
| 2011 | B'klyn Nazareth (C) | Arch. Molloy (C) | L.I. Lutheran (A) | |
| 2010 | Christ The King (C) | Averill Park | Irvington | |
| 2009 | St. Michael Acad. (C) | Kellenberg Mem. (C) | Nanuet | |
| 2008 | Murry Bergtraum (P) | Christ The King (C) | Briarcliff | |
| 2007 | Murry Bergtraum (P) | Mary Louis Acad. (C) | Notre Dame Acad. (C) | |
| 2006 | Christ The King (C) | St. Peter's (C) | Bronx Aquinas (C) | |
| 2005 | Christ The King (C) | Holy Trinity (C) | John Glenn | |
| 2004 | Murry Bergtraum (P) | Arch. Molloy (C) | Holy Trinity (C) | |
| | | | | |
| | Class A | Class B | Class C | Class D |
| 2003 | Murry Bergtraum (P) | St. John Villa (C) | Arch. Molloy (C) | St. Dominic (C) |
| 2002 | Murry Bergtraum (P) | Pough. Lourdes | Brooklyn Kearney (C) | Mary Louis Acad. (C) |
| 2001 | Colonie | Pough. Lourdes | St. John Villa (C) | Kellenberg Mem. (C) |
| 2000 | Christ The King (C) | Pough. Lourdes | Msgr. Scanlan (C) | Haldane |
| 1999 | Christ The King (C) | Pough. Lourdes | Card. Spellman (C) | Batavia Notre Dame |
| 1998 | Christ The King (C) | Oneonta | Brooklyn Kearney (C) | Bronx Riverdale (A) |
| 1997 | Christ The King (C) | Buff. Holy Angels (C) | Burke Catholic | Buff. Nichols (A) |
| 1996 | Christ The King (C) | Saint Dominic (C) | Westhill | Haldane |
| 1995 | Christ The King (C) | St. Francis Prep (C) | Pough. Lourdes | Mount St. Ursula (C) |
| 1994 | Christ The King (C) | Ursuline School | Pough. Lourdes | St. Johnsville |
| 1993 | Christ The King (C) | St. Joseph Hill (C) | Pough. Lourdes | St. Johnsville |
| 1992 | Christ The King (C) | Albertus Magnus | Pough. Lourdes | Buff. Sacred Heart (C) |
| 1991 | Christ The King (C) | Albertus Magnus | Buff. Holy Angels (C) | Our Lady of Mercy (C) |
| 1990 | Christ The King (C) | Syracuse Nottingham | Irvington | Morrisville-Eaton |
| 1989 | August Martin (P) | Syracuse Nottingham | St. Dominics (C) | Haldane |
| 1988 | August Martin (P) | Syracuse Nottingham | Salamanca | Eldred |
| 1987 | St. Peter's (C) | Pough. Lourdes | Wyandanch | Germantown |
| 1986 | Moore Catholic (C) | Penn Yan | Yonkers Sac. Heart (C) | Germantown |
| 1985 | August Martin (P) | Moore Catholic (C) | St. Peter's (C) | Morrisville-Eaton |
| 1984 | August Martin (P) | Nottingham | Marlboro | Tuxedo |
| 1983 | Utica Notre Dame | Westbury | Wyandach | Tuxedo |
| 1982 | Hempstead | Warwick | Marlboro | Tuxedo |
