| School(s) | Year | Record |
| Archbishop Molloy-CHSAA | 1957-58 | 33-0 |
| Abraham Lincoln-PSAL | 2002-03 | 31-1 |
| Wings Academy-PSAL | 2005-06 | 31-1 |
| Abraham Lincoln-PSAL | 2005-06 | 31-4 |
| Boys & Girls-PSAL | 2006-07 | 31-3 |
| Tolentine-CHSAA | 1987-88 | 30-1 |
| St. Ann-CHSAA | 1953-54 | 29-1 |
| St. Ann-CHSAA | 1956-57 | 29-3 |
| Mount Vernon-1 | 1990-91 | 29-0 |
| Prattsburgh-5 | 1990-91 | 29-0 |
| Norwich-4 | 1992-93 | 29-0 |
| Rice-CHSAA | 2001-02 | 29-2 |
| Paul Robeson-PSAL | 2001-02 | 29-4 |
| Jamesville-DeWitt-3 | 2003-04 | 29-0 |
| McKinney-PSAL | 2003-04 | 29-4 |
| Abraham Lincoln-PSAL | 2004-05 | 29-4 |
| Abraham Lincoln-PSAL | 2007-08 | 29-4 |
| | | |
| | | |
The NYSSWA compiles a list of teams with 28 or more victories. This list was last updated July 27, 2008 with information published in Volume 41, Issue 37 of the weekly newsletter.
The complete list is available exclusively in the print edition of the weekly NYSSWA newsletter.
