Key: (A)-AIS, (C)-CHSAA, (P)-PSAL. All others are NYPSHSAA schools.

	Class AA	Class A	Class B
2009	Rice (C)	L.I. Lutheran (A)	Collegiate (A)
2008	Abraham Lincoln (P)	Jamesville-DeWitt	Collegiate (A)
2007	Abraham Lincoln (P)	Peekskill	Malverne
2006	Mount Vernon	Peekskill	Global Studies (P)
2005	Niagara Falls	St. Anthony's (C)	Regis (C)
2004	Mount Vernon	Jamesville-Dewitt	John F. Kennedy
	Class A	Class B	Class C
2003	Abraham Lincoln (P)	Amityville	Brooklyn Friends (A)
2002	Rice (C)	Manhasset St. Mary (C)	Lawrence Woodmere (A)
2001	St. Raymond's (C)	Amityville	Buffalo Traditional
2000	Mount Vernon	Manhasset St. Mary (C)	Brooklyn Poly Prep (A)
1999	Rice (C)	Buff. Turner-Carroll (C)	Lawrence Woodmere (A)
1998	Rice (C)	Westhampton	Buff. Turner-Carroll (C)
1997	Long Is. Lutheran (A)	St. Dominic (C)	New Ro. Salesian (C)
1996	Rice (C)	Peekskill	Buffalo Traditional
1995	Abraham Lincoln (P)	Mount St. Michael (C)	Buffalo Nichols (A)
1994	Rice (C)	Long Is. Lutheran (A)	Cardinal O'Hara (C)
1993	St. Raymond's (C)	Norwich	Regis (C)
1992	Bishop Loughlin (C)	Syracuse Fowler	Seneca Falls Mynderse
1991	Mount Vernon	Syracuse Nottingham	Watervliet
1990	Grady (P)	Jamesville-DeWitt	Buffalo Nichols (A)
1989	Christ The King (C)	Nazareth (C)	Lyons
1988	Tolentine (C)	Niagara Falls LaSalle	Buff. Turner-Carroll (C)
1987	Our Sav. Lutheran (A)	Syracuse Nottingham	Niagara Trott Vocational
	Class A	Class B	Class C	Class D
1986	Binghamton	Xaverian (C)	Buffalo Nichols (A)	Bridgehampton
1985	All Hallows (C)	Samuel Gompers (P)	Buffalo Nichols (A)	Oswego Cunningham
1984	Harry S. Truman (P)	Buffalo Bennett	Rochester Charlotte	Bridgehampton
1983	North Babylon	Bishop Loughlin (C)	Rochester Charlotte	Our Sav. Lutheran (A)
1982	Rochester Franklin (P)	Syracuse Nottingham	Long Is. Lutheran (A)	New York Mills
1981	Xaverian (C)	Malverne	Long Is. Lutheran (A)	Our Sav. Lutheran (A)
1980	Holy Trinity (C)	Tolentine (C)	St. Dominic (C)	Bridgehampton
	Class AAA	Class AA	Class A	Class B
1979	St. Anthony's (C)	Nazareth (C)	St. Agnes (C)	St. John Neumann (C)