New York State Sportswriters Association   
→ Rankings
NYSSWA rankings are updated weekly.
See the latest plus the earlier weeks'
updates on our rankings page.

→ User tools


Thursday, Nov, 12, 2015: Tough break for Sauquoit Valley, but ...

   Leading off today: As sympathetic as I am to the Sauquoit Valley girls soccer team, the purported remedy to an unfortunate situation they experienced in NYSPHSAA Class C quarterfinals is straight out of Fantasy Island.

   Here's what happened during a 2-0 loss to Elmira Notre Dame as told by

   Trailing by a goal early in the second half, Sauquoit Valley's Adrianna Grande broke behind the defense with the ball and was 1-on-1 with the goalie inside the penalty area. As she prepared to attack, a whistle could clearly be heard -- but the whistle came from the stands, apparently by a fan in the Notre Dame section.

   Grande stopped. The Notre Dame defense hesitated, then caught up and cleared the ball to the side, at which point game officials stopped play to sort out what had happened. Ultimately, they awarded the ball to Notre Dame on a throw-in.

   Tim Clive, who has coached Sauquoit Valley for 21 years, said it was unprecedented and that his team should have been awarded a penalty kick. Clive told the website fans were warned before the game that a noisemaker would lead to a penalty kick.

   I'll gently disagree about the unprecedented part, though such glitches are admittedly rare, and I'll vigorously protest the idea that any action by a fan should be grounds for any "solution" as drastic as a penalty kick. Here's why:

   There are no absolutes in sports in large part because no two situations are identical. No one in his right mind should expect a penalty kick to be called over a stray whistle if the ball is 75 or 50 yards from the goal. Nor should it happen 30 yards from the goal. Maybe you start the discussion if the ball is inside the penalty area as in Saturday's case, but does that apply if the offensive player is going 1-on-1 against a defender? How about 1-on-2? What if it's a clean breakaway, but heading toward a showdown with a goalie more skilled than the attacker? What if the whistle didn't come from a fan of the defending team?

   More importantly, a whistle from the stands can certainly create chaos; the awarding of penalty kicks for such infractions guarantees chaos. The alleged offender in Saturday's game was an adult (treat that as an observation about his physical age and not his maturity). Once you start telling fans that they can drastically affect the game by means of penalty kicks for bad behavior, you're practically inviting such shenanigans, especially by younger spectators.

   What happened to Sauquoit Valley was certainly unfortunate, but it's also unreasonable to assume it was a game-changer or impossible to overcome given that it took place with about 35 minutes left in regulation. Notre Dame was already leading and went on to gain breathing room with another goal midway through the second half, well before a team on the short end of the score has to start taking risks leading to counterattack breakaways.

   Eye-opening numbers: With numerous athletes signing scholarship papers this week, Mike Dougherty of The Journal News took a look at the harsh reality of college lacrosse: Lots of kids earn scholarship money, but few pull down amounts of aid that can put a huge dent in the bill mom and dad will end up paying.

   Though NCAA statistics show Division I and II schools dole out $2.7 billion to athletes each year, some sports are more blessed than others. A fully funded college lacrosse team has an average of only 3.15 full scholarships available per year, to be distributed to as many as 10 or 12 recruits. Three-point-something divided by 10 doesn't go very far.

   "It becomes a realization at the beginning of the recruiting process," said John Jay senior attackman Matt Lupinacci, who'll attend Colgate next fall. "You hear a lot from kids who


  • 2015 NYSPHSAA football brackets
  • 2015 Long Island football brackets
  • Football weekly schedules
  • 2015 NYSPHSAA boys soccer brackets
  • 2015 NYSPHSAA girls soccer brackets
  • 2015 NYSPHSAA field hockey brackets

  • claim they got this or they got that. Really, if you end up with a little money for room and board, maybe something for books, that's a lot."

       Dougherty's summary: "Here's the lesson for parents: All that money that you spent over the years for individual lessons, summer travel programs and fitness

    training isn't coming back. But even if the investment only guarantees a spot on the high school team, it's money well spent.

       Following up: As of Thursday afternoon, more than $20,000 had been raised to help Syracuse Corcoran girls basketball coach Jim Marsh defray expenses as he battles cancer. Much of it came from a massive 32-team tournament conducted Saturday at several area schools.

       "It was super -- and a memory I'll have for the rest of my life," Marsh told "It was like a family environment."

       Quite a career: Herb Baker has retired as the boys soccer coach at Jasper-Troupsburg after 557 victories, 13 Section 5 championships and two NYSPHSAA crowns.

       "I decided it was about time before the season started," Baker told The Leader. "It was a gradual thing. I've been at it a long time, 46 years. It's time to let somebody else take over."

       The Wildcats went 14-4-1 this fall in Baker's 46th and final season. His season concludes this weekend with induction into the New York State Soccer Hall of Fame during the state final four.

       "One of the big things is the attitude of the kids," Baker said. "They come to practice and they're ready to work hard. They go to the games and they're ready to play hard. Our youth program was one of the first to start, so that was important to us. Other people are doing it now, but ours has kept going also and that's kept us there."

    → Recent blogs and news     NYSSWA RSS feed
  • 11/17: Moriah rides walk-off pick 6 to semis
  • 11/17: Rauber nabs 4th cross country title
  • 11/17: Lansing boys one win from three-peat
  • 11/16: Red-hot Canandaigua in semifinals
  • 11/14: Investigation sidelines New Ro coach
  • 11/11: Weekly New York City football recap
  • 11/8: Sec. 5 revokes newspapers' credentials
  • 11/7: Cain blasts Salazar, Oregon Project
  • 11/6: Haldane girls win states opener on PKs
  • 11/5: Mercy senior wins state singles title
  • 11/4: Weekly New York City football recap
  • 11/4: Frewsburg girls win marathon shootout
  • This Site

    ©2007-19 Abbott Trento Online Media. All rights reserved. Contact us via e-mail.

    → Twitter
       Get all the latest:

    Follow the NYSSWA on Twitter

    Road To Syracuse H.S. football in New York   Ten Man Ride H.S. lacrosse in New York
    Road To Glens Falls boys H.S. basketball in N.Y.   Road To Troy girls H.S. basketball in N.Y.