New York State Sportswriters Association   
    
Search
 
→ Rankings
NYSSWA rankings are updated weekly.
See the latest plus the earlier weeks'
updates on our rankings page.

 
 
→ User tools

 

Friday, Oct. 28, 2011: Skaneateles booted from playoffs, reinstated by court

   Leading off today: In a normal week, Central New York football observers might have spent today relishing the thought of former Syracuse University teammates Tim Green and Byron Abraham having to coach against each other this Saturday in the Section 3 Class C semifinals.

   Well, not so much anymore.

   In a dramatic series of developments Friday, Skaneateles was thrown out of the playoffs by Section 3 in the morning and reinstated -- for now -- by a New York State Supreme Court justice in the afternoon. Consequently, Skaneateles (8-0, ranked third in Class C by the New York State Sportswriters Association) and Utica Notre Dame will play on Saturday in Chittenango as originally scheduled, with the winner one game away from the NYSPHSAA quarterfinals.

   Skaneateles was granted a temporary restraining order by Justice Brian DeJoseph to block sanctions handed down hours earlier in a meeting of approximately 60 members of the Section 3 Athletic Council. Representatives of the school and the section will return to court on Tuesday; it's uncertain how long it might take for DeJoseph to hear witnesses and render a decision.

   Green emerged from the courtroom -- where procedings were held away from the public and reporters -- shortly after 5 p.m. to announce the judge's decision, saying, "I'm very happy to announce our kids in Skaneateles can play football," The Post-Standard reported.

   The day's drama continued an apparently unprecedented series of events in New York high school sports. Capping a five-month investigation, the school on Tuesday reported evidence of as many as nine instances of unidentified coaches trying to recruit students from other schools over the past two years. Green has maintained his innocence.

   The Post-Standard reported Friday that Skaneateles was censured by the section a year ago for using a player who had not met the requirement for the minimum number of football practices. At that time, Skaneateles was warned that it could face more substantial penalties if the school district committed any further violations of eligibility or sports standards. NYSPHSAA rules provide individual sections with the power to bar a school from athletic contests for up to a year.

   Utica Notre Dame coach surprised: Utica Notre Dame AD Gene Leuthauser was informed in the morning that his team’s game had been suspended, at which time Section 3 Executive Director John Rathbun asked him if the school would be able to play on a different date if necessary.

   "I just told him whatever Section 3 instructs us to do, we’ll gladly play when and where they ask," he told The Post-Standard.

   Abraham was planning to hold its scheduled practice and pregame meal Friday, even if they’ve been told the game was called off.

   "It’s disappointing, I think, for all of the people involved," he told the paper. "For the community of Skaneateles? My goodness. I couldn’t imagine being in something like that."

   When told the case might be headed for court, Abraham reacted with shock. "From my standpoint, how does the Supreme Court get involved in a high school football game? It’s amazing."

   Uncharted territory: Longtime observers I've corresponded with this week couldn't recall anything close to as jolting happening in the NYSPHSAA postseason. Making the situation more dramatic and urgent, football is a once-a-week sport, and teams are required to have four nights of rest between games. A protracted drama brought

  
RoadToSyracuse.com
RoadToSyracuse.com football site

on by delays in State Supreme Court or subsequent appeals could throw the schedule into chaos -- particularly since Skaneateles has looked like a contender to reach the state finals on Thanksgiving weekend in Syracuse.

   The only situation I can recall that came remotely close because of its impact on the state championships came when McQuaid went to court in May 1989 to gain reinstatement after being banned from the Section 5 outdoor track championships.

   By extension, the penalty would have kept McQuaid out of the state meet as well. But the school's lawyer successfully argued that McQuaid's coaches did not violate a rule pertaining to the

Read the tweets
   Many reporters use Twitter to deliver remote updates. We track those tweets from a variety of venues 24/7. Visit the page to see what's going on.
Read the tweets

number of contests because none of its athletes competed in more than the maximum number of meets. The Knights' 3,200-meter relay subsequently won a NYSPHSAA title.

   Other states have had football playoff issues decided in court in recent years.

   In 2005, Oklahoma's State Supreme Court was asked to rule whether a state quarterback, suspended for kicking an opponent 19 seconds from the end of a state quarterfinal, should be reinstated. State semifinals were postponed twice and the governor -- a graduate of the affected school -- caused a stir by questioning Oklahoma Secondary Schools Activities Association rules.

   Last fall, West Virginia's Supreme Court ruled that a circuit judge exceeded her authority when she allowed four South Charleston players to compete in the football semifinals following another fight-related punishment. The justices sided with the West Virginia Secondary School Activities Commission, which appealed after Kanawha Circuit Judge Carrie Webster allowed the four to play in the semifinal win and in the postponed championship game.    The WVSSAC required South Charleston to forfeit its 29-28 semifinal victory and moved Brooke High into the final.

   The West Virginia outcome does raise an interesting issue with regard to this weekend. Should Utica Notre Dame loses to Skaneateles, the fact that there was a disciplinary ruling beforehand would seem to mean the team would be in line to receive a forfeit -- as opposed to having the other semifinal winner advance on a bye.

   And here's the elephant in the room that no one wants to consider: What if Notre Dame gets players hurt on Saturday and then the Lakers lose in court?


→ Recent blogs and news     NYSSWA RSS feed
  • 6/26/25: All-state softball team announced
  • 6/17/25: Albany Academy basketball heads to NEPSAC
  • 6/11/25: L.I. school says mascot change costs $23M
  • 6/4/25: Orchard Park has had a huge spring season
  • 6/1/25: Plainview JFK flag football finally loses game
  • 5/30/25: Miller Place star extends state discus mark

  • 5/29/25: Supporters rally behind Sec. 9 softball coach
  • 5/25/25: Williamsville East moves on without coach
  • 5/23/25: Sec. 6 baseball team accused of tanking game
  • 5/23/25: NYSPHSAA, PSAL, CHSAA flag football update
  • 5/17/25: Wayne's Blankenberg opts for prep school
  • 5/16/25: Section 2 hits La Salle with playoff ban
  • 5/9/25: Three-Region Concept hits a speed bump
  • 5/8/25: Girls basketball all-state team (AAA, AA, and A)
  • 5/5/25: Previewing the quarterly NYSPHSAA meeting
  • 5/5/25: Girls basketball all-state team (B, C, and D)

  • 5/2/25: Ad hoc committee to pitch public vs. private plan
  • 4/30/25: DA: Charges pending against Westhill athletes
  • 4/27/25: Boys basketball all-state team (AAA, AA, and A)
  • 4/26/25: Title-winning SWR coach Adrian Gilmore dies
  • 4/25/25: Sports and politicians: Not a good mix
  • 4/21/25: Boys basketball all-state team (B, C, and D)
  • 4/16/25: Art and Linda Kranick resign at Saratoga
  • 4/14/25: Sec. 5 coach may have set 2 marks with 1 win
  • 4/12/25: Miles ties NYSPHSAA mark for baseball wins
  • 4/5/25: Warrensburg/Lake George/Bolton picks Irion

  • 4/4/25: NY's eight-man football surge is subsiding
  • 3/29/25: Sec. 1 football schedule has coaches uneasy
  • 3/28/25: Did a book cost longtime Sec. 3 coach his job?
  • 3/26/25: Does flag football hurt other spring sports?
  • 3/24/25: Fired Northville coach charged with harassment
  • 3/22/25: Northville fires coach over post-game incident
  • 3/19/25: L.I. parents bring racism concerns to board
  • 3/14/25: NFHS Hall of Fame inducting St. Johnsville star
  • 3/7/25: Battaglia set for 3rd tour of duty at Aquinas
  • 3/7/25: Schedule of N.Y. boys basketball title games

  • 3/6/25: Court OK's Zariel Macchia to run Saturday
  • 3/5/25: Aquinas fires football coach after semifinal run
  • 3/1/25: Newburgh dismisses Bianco as football coach
  • 2/27/25: Court reinstates L.I. hoops star for sectionals
  • 2/22/25: Distance star Macchia out of state meet
  • 2/14/25: Remarkable efforts in WNY girls basketball
  • 2/8/25: NYSPHSAA working way through 2 big topics
  • 2/6/25: Three-Region Concept is on the fast track
  • 2/1/25: Minisink Valley, John Glenn wrestlers prevail
  • 1/31/25: 2024 girls basketball all-state team named

  • 1/25/25: NYC, L.I. restore football all-star game
  • 1/18/25: Colonie bowler's 890 series sets U.S. mark
  • 1/16/25: Somers football likely to remain in Class A
  • 1/15/25: All-state football: Classes AA and A
  • 1/14/25: Harper steps down at Clymer/Sherman/Panama
  • 1/10/25: Four L.I. districts still battling mascot rule
  • 1/8/25: All-state football: Classes B, C, D and 8-man
  • 12/20/24: Canastota's Laidlaw chalks up 900th win
  • 12/17/24: William Floyd assistant dies in car crash
  • 12/11/24: AD at Sec. 2 powerhouse will step down

  • 12/9/24: Girls soccer all-state selections announced
  • 12/8/24: Recapping the weekend NYSPHSAA football finals
  • 12/7/24: Which mascots replaced Indians, Warriors?
  • 12/6/24: Publics vs. privates issue resurfaces
  • 12/5/24: NYSPHSAA makes rare mid-year class change
  • 12/2/24: Short-handed Conn. team forfeits playoff game
  • 12/1/24: Massapequa hockey player dies during game
  • 11/27/24: Column: Crisis in Sec. 5 small-school football
  • 11/24/24: PSAL cracks down, imposes hoops forfeits
  • 11/22/24: Bayport-Blue Point football extends streaks

  • 11/19/24: Some thoughts following the playoffs weekend
  • 11/15/24: Plainedge football pulls off last-play win
  • 11/8/24: Court restores Syracuse ITC to grid playoffs
  • 11/6/24: West Islip girls soccer advances on PKs
  • 11/5/24: Newburgh forfeits sectional football opener
  • 11/2/24: Top-ranked 'D' football team's season over
  • 10/31/24: Herricks' Walia wins state tennis singles title
  • 10/28/24: S-WR senior making the grade in 2 sports
  • 10/27/24: Copiague football ends its record losing streak
  • 10/26/24: Herkimer gridders claw way back to .500

  • 10/25/24: Girls lacrosse schedule proposal nixed
  • 10/22/24: NYSPHSAA Exec Committee meeting preview
  • 10/19/24: Albany CBA wins Sec. 2 football showdown
  • 10/18/24: Baldwinsville cracks 'USAT' eSports rankings
  • 10/16/24: Wisc. hits schools hard for paperwork glitch
  • 10/14/24: Bethlehem girls, Macchia win Eastern States
  • 10/13/24: Iona Prep slips past Hayes in 'AA" showdown
  • 10/11/24: La. QB throws for 817 yards in overtime loss
  • 10/10/24: Report: N.Y. girls to join transgender protest
  • 10/7/24: More eight-man teams left stranded in Week 5

  • 10/5/24: 18 ranked N.Y. football teams fall in Friday action
  • 10/4/24: Longest U.S. football futility streak continues
  • 10/3/24: Syracuse.com's twist on fantasy football
  • 9/30/24: M-E edges Waverly in battle of No. 1 teams
  • 9/27/24: Report: Sec. 3 athletes flock to NIL Club
  • 9/25/24: Ex-Kellenberg QB sets off an NIL drama
  • 9/23/24: NYSPHSAA warns about potential NIL isssue
  • 9/21/24: South Park's Nunes shatters N.Y. rushing record
  • 9/20/24: Storytelling in H.S. sports is alive and well
  • 9/19/24: Longtime SWR coach Paul Koretzki, 84, dies

  • 9/17/24: Western N.Y. teams embracing Guardian Caps
  • 9/15/24: N.J. shows us N.Y. football has a ways to go
  • 9/14/24: Another UPrep game, another fan incident
  • 9/13/24: Ohio wrestles with aftermath of shootings
  • 9/11/24: Mass. school forfeits over male opponent
  • 9/10/24: Regents table vote on expanding mixed competition
  • 9/9/24: Shot clock experiment will change lacrosse
  • 9/7/24: Garden City sets L.I. football record
  • 9/6/24: Lawsuit takes aim at N.C.'s NIL ban
  • 9/5/24: New York's Week 0 football intrigue

  •   
    This Site
    HOME
    BLOG
    RANKINGS
    BRACKETS
    REFERENCE
    KERR CUP
    ABOUT US

    ©2024 Abbott Trento Online Media.
    All rights reserved.
    Contact us via e-mail.

       NYSSWA football site