Leading off today: After close to 30 years in the business of covering high school sports, I understand full well there's no such thing as the offseason when it comes to criticizing officiating.
For instance, there were people upset with Sunday's Long Island Class AA state basketball quarterfinal, in which Half Hollow Hills West edged Elmont 79-75 in two overtimes. Elmont was whistled for 28 fouls, which seems a bit high, even for a two-OT affair. Three players fouled out in the loss and HHH West attempted 37 free throws to 13 for Elmont.
But that's not really enough information to judge the officiating. Were the refs calling the game too tight or was Elmont playing too aggressively? You have to watch the whole game to start making an informed assessment of how well the officials performed; even then, you could probably put four observers in a room and come up with five different opinions.
That's not so much the case, though, in the Williamsville East-Pelham hockey semifinal in Utica on Saturday. Williamsville East advanced with a 3-2 victory on what appears to have been a phantom goal 2:34 into the second OT.
Pelham turned the puck over on an attempt to clear the defensive zone, and two Williamsville East skaters came alone on goalie Josh Borofsky. Cole Weppner fired a shot on goal and the puck seemed to hit the near post, cross the goalmouth and trickle into the corner to Borofsky's left. (View the play here.)
It takes a leap of faith to believe the puck could have gone in the net and then slid harmlessly away the way it did; in fact, no goal light came on and skaters were still playing the puck. But the referee blew his whistle and signaled the puck was in. Game over.
"I heard the puck go off the post and I got really scared," Borofsky told The Journal News. "I saw the play continuing on and I saw where the puck ended up. There's no way it went in the net."
Hockey stars selected: Williamsville North senior goaltender Parker Gahagen was selected the Division I