| Player | School | Season | Points |
| Chuck Kinney | Peru-7 | 1954-55 | 98 |
| Ed Smith | Commerce-NYC | 1962-63 | 88 |
| Marcus Whitfield | Buffalo Burgard-6 | 1988-89 | 80 |
| Pat Stark | Syracuse Vocational-3 | 1948-49 | 78 |
| Mike Milligan | Lutheran-AIS | 1977-78 | 76 |
| Trevor Ruffin | Buffalo Bennett-6 | 1987-88 | 76 |
| Dammell Lenoir | McKee Tech-NYC | 1996-97 | 76 |
| Ken White | Monsignor Farrell-NYC | 1987-88 | 75 |
| Scott Wilson | Lyme-3 | 1981-82 | 74 |
| Don Hurlbert | Hinsdale-6 | 1968-69 | 70 |
| Wayne McKoy | Lutheran-AIS | 1976-77 | 70 |
| Jerry Houston | LaSalle-NYC | 1957-58 | 69 |
| Vilius Raulus | Buffalo Christian | 2001-02 | 69 |
| Jack Costello | Gompers-NYC | 1946-47 | 68 |
| Greg Meyer | New Rochelle Salesian-1 | 1960-61 | 68 |
| | | | |
| | | | |
The NYSSWA compiles a list of players with 60 or more points in a game. This list was last updated July 27, 2008 with information published in Volume 41, Issue 31 of the weekly newsletter.
The complete list of more than 70 players is available exclusively in the print edition of the weekly NYSSWA newsletter.
