| Coach | School(s) | Wins | '08-09 season |
| Jack Curran | Archbishop Molloy-CHSAA | 914 | 16 wins |
| Ed Petrie | East Hampton-11 | 746 | 23 wins |
| Chuck Granby | Jackson, Campus Magnet-PSAL | 665 | 14 wins |
| Jack Halloran | Whitney Point-4 | 630 | Retired |
| Dudly Maxim | Trinity School-NYC | 619 | Retired |
| Bob Clark | Riverdale-NYC | 599 | Retired |
| Bill Merna | Hammond, Ogdensburg Free-10 | 584 | 19 wins |
| Tom Murray | Cardinal Hayes-NYC | 582 | Retired |
| Floyd Bank | Edison, Collegiate, DRS - NYC | 579 | Retired |
| Larry Byrnes | Collegiate School-NYC | 577 | Retired |
| Rod Chando | Red Hook-9 | 568 | 19 wins |
| Tim Leary | St. Francis Prep-NYC | 566 | 8 wins |
| Jim Gatto | St. John's Prep-NYC | 562 | 11 wins |
| Jerry Kaplan | Highland Falls O'Neill-9 | 560 | Retired |
| Ron Naclerio | Cardozo-PSAL | 550 | 22 wins |
| Bob Oliva | Christ The King-CHSAA | 549 | Retired |
| George Mardigan | Watervliet-2 | 546 | Retired |
| Ed Nietopski | Card. Mooney, Bishop Kearney-5 | 545 | Retired |
| Mel Palano | Buffalo Bishop Timon-CHSAA | 544 | Retired |
| Harry Moskowitz | James Madison-NYC | 541 | Retired |
| John Volpe | Gorton, Sacred Heart-1 | 528 | Retired |
| Roger Rigby | Scio-5 | 527 | Retired |
| Mike Rapone | Batavia Notre Dame-5 | 527 | 18 wins |
| Al Knapp | Brookfield, V-V-S-3 | 523 | 16 wins |
| Dave Powers | Oswego-3 | 520 | Retired |
| George Khoury | Warrensburg-2 | 518 | Retired |
| Jim Burke | Prattsburgh-5 | 517 | 18 wins |
| Charlie Folsom | Harrisville-10 | 515 | Retired |
| Bob Hettler | Amherst-6 | 514 | Retired |
| Paul Lyons | Albany-2 | 514 | Retired |
| Mike Del Val | Alexander Hamilton, Rye-1 | 514 | Retired |
| Jim Zullo | Shenendehowa, Broad.-Perth-2 | 513 | 15 wins |
| | Indian Lake-7 | | |
| Lou Panzanaro | Peekskill-1 | 510 | 24 wins |
| Jim Franco | Catskill-2 | 485 | Retired |
| Randy Beageal | Wells-7 | 483 | Retired |
| | | | |
| | | | |
| | | | |
| | | | |
The NYSSWA compiles a list of coaches with 400 or more career victories. This list was last updated on Dec. 20, 2009 with information published in Volume 43, Issue 21 of the weekly newsletter.
That complete list of more than 80 coaches is available exclusively in the print edition of the weekly NYSSWA newsletter.
